Extended Abstracts
LIN Mengquan; CHEN Yan; LI Yong; ZHANG Jin
Education is the cornerstone and core of economic, social, and scientific development. In the face of increasingly fierce international competition, countries around the world have launched various key construction strategies to enhance the comprehensive strength and competitiveness of national education. Effectiveness evaluation, as a special measure to test the effectiveness of national and regional key construction, is an inevitable need for higher education development to a high level, when compared with licensing evaluation, educational accreditation, and ranking from the perspective of the need to reform the supply of evaluation models and methods at the stage of education development. However, there are few theoretical and practical studies on the topic of effectiveness evaluation of university disciplines in domestic and foreign literature, and no systematic theoretical system and model has been formed yet, not to mention the scientific implementation system. This paper systematically studies the content and classification of the evaluation of the effectiveness of university disciplines. This paper considers that effectiveness evaluation is the examination of the achievements, results, and effects of the development of university disciplines within a certain period of time based on the predefined conditions, scope, and goals. According to the evaluation needs, three types of effectiveness evaluation are defined for the first time: absolute, relative, and value-added effectiveness, which provides the theoretical basis and foundation for the effectiveness evaluation classification function. On this basis, a new method of three-dimensional system is proposed, and it includes construction task elements, elements of task completion and development effect, and evaluation method elements. Based on this, a two-dimensional matrix structure framework is established, and feasibility analysis is conducted on the composition of the construction task dimension and four dimensions. After that, the application expression of matrix system decomposition is given, and the advantages of this method are demonstrated. In order to apply the effectiveness evaluation more effectively, guidelines are given for its application in university disciplines, and four application strategies are proposed, namely, the formulation of evaluation objectives, the analysis of evaluation objects, the construction of evaluation system, and the principles and paths of evaluation method selection. Finally, the authors analyze the factors influencing the credibility of the results and the areas where the results can be applied, thus forming a set of theoretical frameworks and implementation strategies for effectiveness evaluation. This paper expands and innovates in the following aspects. Firstly, it systematically defines the content and functions of educational effectiveness and effectiveness evaluation and provides the basis for the research in this field. Secondly, it proposes for the first time a new model of constructing a three-dimensional thinking system for effectiveness evaluation, which makes the content of the system more comprehensive, effective, and usable through the logical relationship of the development goal, development achievement, and evaluation mechanism of the evaluation objects. Thirdly, based on the theory of the three-dimensional system construction, an original model of a two-dimensional structure effectiveness evaluation system is established. It has the special function of testing the achievement characteristics of educational tasks and goals and development degrees. Fourthly, four paths of effectiveness evaluation implementation are proposed to ensure its special function performing and indicate the application scenarios and strategies, which provide theoretical and application references for university discipline effectiveness evaluation in the new era. To a certain extent, this paper reveals the inner logic of university discipline evaluation, provides a new paradigm for the continued research in this field, helps the organizers and undertakers of education key construction projects to carry out effectiveness evaluation practically, has certain theoretical and practical significance in promoting education evaluation reform and theoretical innovation, and helps to improve the modernization of higher education governance system and governance capacity.